The Hardships of Living in the Past
Ali Reza Naderi, Scriptwriter
The Impediments of Ali Hatami’s Cinema
Translated by Mohammad Karimi
A long alley forward; a way toward the “past”, a long alley that goes back forever, and an alley that goes forward to “future”, these two are against each other but both will reach to “eternity”.
All the artists would work on one of these: past, present and future; no matter if they are at their “motherland” or “exile”, in “travel” or “settled”. Ali Hatami –who is from our past by the order of death-, has often written about “past” while living in present! “home, memoir and language”, are made in the “past”; it is deep common wonder, to live in the moment and think about memoirs, making memoirs and living with them!
The paper had to be written for Mother, but it is not; about Hatami and the value of his memoirs, but it is not; it is about the “ones” who worked with Hatami.
Hatami worked in theatre, cinema and literature at the time when official cultural institutions were thinking about the country’s modernization and future with their broad and artificial bureaucratic structure for a delirious kind of development. Hatami was living in a close past and looking in his memoirs for the hints that could be used for an artistic job; something like an endless conflict with what the government was looking after!
It is clear that Hatami was looking for something that government was doing its best to wipe it out! Surely you know how willingly Pahlavis moved out Qadjars and their lassitude from the Iranian nation’s path and how proud of it they were! The art of Hatami and the mystery of his victory in this conflict was the picture which he drew of the “past”. This “past” is still something that gives a deep nostalgic feeling to the ones who wish for those days’ literature and costumes. The days without newspaper, with a government led by a dumb and retarded king, courtiers chosen from the underlings and incapable people, and a harem full of dirt and stench; but … Hatami narrates the Qadjars’ past so skillfully that Shah is believed to be great king and his only fault is killing Amir and …
The past literature, history, notable texts or some newspapers, objects and structures and all the other things belonging to the past, all were shining materials to Hatami; while the art of that era was principally going toward modernism and all the old objects were about to be in trash and away!
In this short writing, I am pointing to those clever and stylist officials who understood Hatami at that time! The official whose priorities were not given by official orders and sanctions; the ones who accepted the risk and believed his thoughts and considerations, his Sultan of Sahibqeran …and opened the way for a young man who was going toward the two eternities, the “past” and “future”. The man who had chosen past while the regime was hardly trying to fill the “moment” of people, or at most drowning them in the future unreal delusions! Where are the clever officials, who understood at the “moment”, what would be the “future” for Hatami who was searching for the “past”?!
Hamshahri-ye Mah (Monthly Hamshahri), Special Issue, No. 58, page: 87, Nov. 2010
Number of Visits: 6854
The latest
- Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War Doctor – 11
- 100 Questions/10
- The 23rd Commemoration Ceremony of the Martyrs of the Ansar al-Rasul Battalion Held
- A Narrative of Pakistani Pedestrian Pilgrims of Arbaeen in Sistan and Baluchestan
- Oral History Methodology/National Archives and Library Organization of Iran, Archives Research Institute
- Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War Doctor – 10
- 100 Questions/9
- Oral History News – Aban 1404
Most visited
- The Relationship between “Religious Jurisprudence” and “Oral History”
- Oral History News – Aban 1404
- Oral History Methodology/National Archives and Library Organization of Iran, Archives Research Institute
- 100 Questions/9
- Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War Doctor – 10
- A Narrative of Pakistani Pedestrian Pilgrims of Arbaeen in Sistan and Baluchestan
- The 23rd Commemoration Ceremony of the Martyrs of the Ansar al-Rasul Battalion Held
- 100 Questions/10
100 Questions/6
We asked several researchers and activists in the field of oral history to express their views on oral history questions. The names of each participant are listed at the beginning of their answers, and the text of all answers will be published on this portal by the end of the week. The goal of this project is to open new doors to an issue and promote scientific discussions in the field of oral history.The Importance of Pre-Publication Critique of Oral History Works
According to the Oral History website, a meeting for critique and review of the book “Oral History: Essence and Method” was held on Monday morning, November 10, 2025, with the attendance of the book’s author, Hamid Qazvini, and the critics Mohammad Qasemipour and Yahya Niazi, at the Ghasr-e Shirin Hall of the National Museum of the Islamic Revolution and Sacred Defense.Challenges of Interviewing in Oral History
After years of studying the theoretical foundations of oral history, conducting numerous interviews and going through their post-interview stages, as well as reading the available body of oral history literature, I was eventually given the opportunity to evaluate the edited versions of dozens of oral history projects.Comparing the Narratives of Commanders and Ordinary Combatants in the Sacred Defense
An Analysis of Functions and ConsequencesThe experience of the Sacred Defense cannot be comprehended merely through statistics or official reports; what truly endures from war are the narratives of those who stood upon its frontlines. These narratives, however, vary significantly depending on one’s position, responsibilities, and lived experience.
