Theories on Oral History as Narrated by Artificial Intelligence
Theory Two: The Borderline Legitimacy Crisis of Oral History in the Academic System
Compiled by Iranian Oral History Website
Translated by Fazel Shirzad
2026-5-26
Oral history is more than just an accumulation of narratives; it is a field of methodical dialogue between memory, power, ethics, and representation. Amidst this, one of the challenges for researchers in this field is transitioning from mere “interview reporting” to “theoretical structuring” (a question to which every expert provides a different answer based on their experience and intellectual framework).
If we were to feed the responses of 13 oral history experts (who have answered a specific question on the Oral History website) into an AI, what patterns and repetitions would emerge? Does AI merely echo a consensus, or can it derive a theory from the plurality of responses?
To find the answer, we analyzed the experts’ responses using the DeepSeek AI and arrived at several theories. From here on, the theories extracted by the AI based on the experts’ responses will be presented sequentially, opening a new chapter in theorizing about oral history.
Theory Two: The Borderline Legitimacy Crisis of Oral History in the Academic System
The more academics emphasize traditional criteria of scientific validity (the historical age of sources, written authenticity, temporal distance from the event, and quantitative methods), the more oral history (due to its reliance on individual memory, subjectivity, the lack of sufficient temporal distance, and the difficulty of verification) is relegated to a “borderline zone” between science and non-science. Consequently, the reluctance of academics is not rooted in the essence of oral history itself, but is the result of its “institutional legitimacy crisis” within a system that has yet to produce evaluation frameworks, educational structures, and promotion criteria commensurate with this field.
Theoretical Background:
This theory was derived based on the responses of 13 oral history experts (Gholamreza Azari Khakestar, Mohammad-Mehdi Behdarvand, Hassan Beheshtipour, Abolfazl Hassanabadi, Hossein Zanjani, Fazel Shirzad, Mohammad-Mehdi Abdollahzadeh, Gholamreza Azizi, Seyed Mohammad-Sadegh Feiz, Hamid Qazvini, Jafar Golshan Roghani, Mohammad-Mohsen Moshafi, and Shafiqeh Nik-Nafs) to the question, “What is the reason for the lack of academic reception of oral history?”
The repetition of concepts such as “traditional view of written sources,” “lack of an independent academic discipline,” “weakness of methodology in education,” “resistance to change,” “difficulty in verifying narratives,” and “emphasis on a fifty-year temporal distance” in these responses led the AI to the pattern you have studied.
Number of Visits: 9
The latest
- Theory Two: The Borderline Legitimacy Crisis of Oral History in the Academic System
- 100 Questions/ 31
- Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War Doctor – 31
- 100 Questions/ 30
- The Story of a Street Classroom
- Validation: Challenges and Necessities
- Memories of Mr. Jalal Setareh
- Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War Doctor – 30
Most visited
- Theory One: “The Structural Duality of Opportunity–Threat in the Government’s Entry into Oral History”
- The 373rd Night of Memories – Part 7
- 100 Questions/ 29
- Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War Doctor – 30
- Memories of Mr. Jalal Setareh
- Validation: Challenges and Necessities
- The Story of a Street Classroom
- 100 Questions/ 30
100 Questions/27
What is the place of research ethics in compiling oral history?We asked several researchers and activists in the field of oral history to express their views on oral history questions. The names of each participant are listed at the beginning of their answers, and the text of all answers will be published on this portal by the end of the week.
Photo Album from The Doctor of fly
The Doctor of fly, authored by Fatemeh Dehghan Niri, presents the memoirs of Dr. Mohammad-Taqi Khorsandi Ashtiani, Professor Emeritus and a subspecialist in Otolaryngology at Tehran University of Medical Sciences. Compiled within the framework of oral history, the work recounts different stages of his life—from childhood and years of ...The Beating Pulse of a Nation at the Moment of Nowruz
Every year, in the days and nights leading up to Nowruz, Shohada Square had a special charm. A few days before the New Year, the shops would fill with customers, and street vendors would take over the sidewalks. You could find everything in their stalls (from items for the Haft Sin table, candles, goldfish, and spring flowers to clothes, bags, and shoes).The Editor's Missing Place on the “Deck”
The book From Deck to Heaven offers a relatively fresh approach to examining the role of the Islamic Republic of Iran Army Navy (AJA) during the eight years of the Sacred Defense, published under the “Oral History of the Islamic Revolution” series. To compile this book, the esteemed author has utilized documentary research (referring to relevant archival centers and selecting documents) and field research ...
